← All work← Back to quest log

Case study · Woolworths Financial ServicesCompleted quest · Woolworths Financial Services

Loyalty programme review

A review of the Difference Rewards loyalty programme to determine its effectiveness - where its spend led to returns, and where it didn't. It led to changes that saved about R16 million a year.

CompanyFaction
Woolworths Financial Services
RoleClass
Senior Analyst, Customer Analytics
YearEra
2018
ToolsGear
SAS · SQL

The problemThe call

Difference Rewards was a core part of the Woolworths offering, but its real contribution to the business wasn't clear. I was asked to evaluate the programme and recommend changes. By comparing the behaviour of customers in the programme with similar customers who weren't, I showed where it was losing money - and the changes I proposed saved about R16 million a year.

ApproachThe run

Step 1

Frame the question

Store card and credit card customers got an extra 5% on top of the usual loyalty discount. The question: was that extra 5% paying for itself?

Step 2

Build like-for-like cohorts

Split programme members and non-members into smaller cohorts and matched similar sub-populations, so any difference reflected the programme rather than the kind of customer who joins it.

Step 3

Compare behaviour

Compared recency, frequency and spend across the matched cohorts. Members did engage more - but not by enough to justify what the programme cost.

Step 4

Recommend the change

Recommended stepping back from the extra 5% on most products. The change was implemented and saved about R16 million a year.

ResultsRewards

~R16msaved a year once the change was implemented
~2%of profit before tax
15% → 10%card-holder discount on most promoted products, with the extra 5% stepped back

Looking backDebrief

This was my first project at Woolworths. I'd joined as a long-term contractor, and the approach I proposed and delivered here led to me being fast-tracked to a permanent role. It set me up for the next four years and opened the door to some of the most interesting work of my career.